Killer was 'skilled at hiding' psychosis symptoms
19 minutes ago
Share
Save
Add as preferred on Google
Asha Patel
East Midlands
Nottinghamshire Police
Valdo Calocane's fatal attacks in Nottingham are being examined at a public inquiry in London.
A nurse has told a public inquiry a mentally ill man who went on to kill three people in a spate of attacks was "skilled at hiding" his symptoms.
Valdo Calocane, who was diagnosed with paranoid schizophrenia, stabbed to death Barnaby Webber, Grace O'Malley-Kumar and Ian Coates, and tried to kill three others in Nottingham on 13 June 2023.
Calocane was under the care of Nottinghamshire Healthcare NHS Foundation Trust in the years leading up the attacks, until he was discharged due to a lack of engagement in September 2022.
In evidence to the
Nottingham Inquiry
- examining the attacks - Claudia Birtles, a mental health nurse, said Calocane was "harder than most [patients]" to assess.
Calocane had a total of four admissions to hospital under the Mental Health Act between May 2020 and February 2022.
Birtles was responsible for coordinating Calocane's care in the community for almost two years, from June 2020 to April 2022.
She was his care coordinator on the Early Intervention Psychosis (EIP) team, which he was referred to after a first admission to a psychiatric ward in May 2020.
Supplied
Barnaby Webber, Grace O'Malley-Kumar and Ian Coates were killed by Valdo Calocane on 13 June 2023
The inquiry heard in September 2021, following a third admission to hospital, there was a "breakdown" in Calocane's relationship with Birtles.
Calocane had appealed his detention to the Mental Health Tribunal for which Birtles completed a report outlining his circumstances.
In that report, which Calocane was able to read, Birtles outlined Calocane's non-concordance with medication and his denial of mental illness.
The inquiry heard Calocane - referred to as VC throughout the inquiry - told Birtles he would no longer share anything with her after reading the report.
During a meeting with Calocane, following discharge from his third admission in February 2022, Birtles recorded "no evidence of overt symptoms of psychosis" but that he was reluctant to share information.
Challenged on her view of Calocane's presentation during that meeting, she said: "I've always said it's been so difficult to assess those symptoms with VC, harder than most, because I believe he was quite skilled at hiding them - but again this was my impression on the day."
Care pathway
Birtles also said she was wrong to describe Calocane in the same report as being "polite" and "law-abiding", despite knowing he had
violently attacked a police officer
and
broken into his neighbours' homes
.
The inquiry heard throughout Calocane's care, he had a history of non-compliance with medication and a lack of "insight" - an understanding and acceptance - of his illness.
Calocane admitted he failed to take his medication from about two weeks after discharge from his first admission, the hearing was told.
However, a depot - long-acting, injectable antipsychotic medication - was never administered.
Following a second admission to hospital in July 2021, Calocane's mother, Celeste, asked if depot medication was an option, the inquiry heard.
During that discussion, Birtles said she was happy with the plan for Calocane to take tablets.
She told the hearing: "I think we focused a lot on his opportunity to take the tablets again, to demonstrate that he can do it."
She added he was "still quite early on" in the care pathway.
However, Birtles later suggested the consideration of using a depot during Calocane's third admission, but said she could not recall a discussion about it.
"Everybody knew there was an issue with concordance, everyone suspected it, and then it was confirmed, so it could have been [discussed]," she said.
Birtles said although she felt administering a depot "was the right thing to do", it would not have "necessarily solved all the issues", adding some patients would still be symptomatic.
The inquiry heard Calocane would have to consent to a depot unless he was subject to a Community Treatment Order under section 3 of the Mental Health Act.
Nottinghamshire Police
Calocane was involved with a number of violent incidents, including attacking a police officer, while under the care of the NHS Trust
Calocane was discharged by the NHS Trust back to his GP, the Cripps Health Centre in Nottingham, in September 2022.
A letter was sent to the GP, but there was no discussion with the surgery or an individual from the surgery about Calocane, the inquiry heard.
Birtles agreed that was "extraordinary" and agreed a discussion with the GP would have been "vital".
Rachel Langdale KC, counsel to the inquiry, said: "And it did need fresh eyes didn't it?
"Because it's frankly absurd that he was discharged in these circumstances, unmedicated and into the community, isn't it?
"I think - I wasn't there for the decision - but I can appreciate that that certainly seems to be the case," Birtles replied.
Calocane is currently serving an indefinite hospital order at a high-security facility after pleading guilty to three counts of manslaughter on the grounds of diminished responsibility and three counts of attempted murder.
The inquiry continues.
Listen to
BBC Radio Nottingham on Sounds
and follow BBC Nottingham on
Facebook
, on
X
, or on
Instagram
. Send your story ideas to
eastmidsnews@bbc.co.uk
or via
WhatsApp
on 0808 100 2210.
More on this story
Mental health nurse admits errors in killer's records
Doctor warned attacker he would end up killing
Killer 'texted brother about murderous thoughts'
Race not a factor in killer's assessment, inquiry told
Former police chief turns down senior review job
Police 'reluctant' to probe attacks footage access
Killer 'hid in the shadows', lawyer tells inquiry
Key takeaways from the Nottingham public inquiry so far
What is the Nottingham public inquiry and how does it work?
Police 'jumped the gun' to charge killer - inquiry
Psychiatrist 'did not view' killer's earlier incidents
Stab victims tested for drugs - but killer was not
Nottingham victim's sons criticise 'yoga studio therapy' offer after attack, inquiry told
Mother of attacks victim urges police footage probe
Body of father was at attacks scene for 15 hours
Nottingham attacks victim's body remained at the scene for 15 hours, public inquiry told
Killer 'should have been arrested before attacks'
Ex-chief constable admits 'fundamental failures' at inquiry into Nottingham killings
Police deny killer was charged to 'shut down stories'
Senior officer suspected Nottingham attacks stories had been leaked to the press, public inquiry told
Nottingham attacks killer 'spooked by police siren'
Inquiry hears 999 call reporting 'awful' stabbings
Officer missed arrest warrant in killer's police log
Killer 'assaulted couple weeks before attacks'
Killer carried names of flatmates during attacks
Triple killer put flatmate in headlock in assault
Killer headbutted and punched police officer
Triple killer's ex-housemate 'left flat out of fear'
Killer broke into flat minutes after being released
Woman fell from window trying to flee triple killer
University 'in the dark' over triple killer's risk
'Serious failure' to arrest triple killer on warrant
Killer watched shooting videos online, inquiry hears
Attacks inquiry a chance 'to confront failure'
The Nottingham Inquiry
Nottingham
Nottingham attacks